Skips

Character's name & rank: Unterfeldwebel Thorfinn Snoreson SteamID (STEAM_0:X:XXX): STEAM_0:0:526256772 Staff member who issued the PK (if you know): Arrow Explain why you were PK'd: breaking fear rp Why should you be un-PK'd?: During my pk the oberst (Arrow) yells ooc terms saying that "im just gonna pk you now" in most situations pks are voided because when you start breaking character the entire rp scenario becomes null and void because you are bringing ooc terms into a in character situation. This makes the rp scenario very low quality and questionable. Another reason this should not be a full pk was the fact that my realistic odds werent terrible with me having in mp40 and the 2 guys with pistols and that slow to react grenadier i had already had my mp40 out before any guns were being pointed at me so it couldnt be seen as a total fear rp pk. I was not pulled into a sit and explained anything i was simply pkd while walking around and makes me wonder if this pk was handled properly and professionally. I feel as if a staff member should know better not to break character in these types of situations. Furthermore i would like to call into question the person who requested the pk had been targeting me all day earlier he had arrested me simply for walking into him and there was no in character reason to arrest me which makes me feel as if this pk was requested based on ooc animosity towards me. All in all i feel that this pk was handled very sloppily and at most i should have gotten an ooc demotion or a name pk. Additional Information: https://medal.tv/games/garrys-mod/clips/lyXRGvGZQcxJJKmyk?invite=cr-MSxnNDYsMjI4NzQzMDM&v=30 - my clip - arrows clip

i type in all lowercase cuz i never cap

Your Name: skips SteamID (STEAM_0:X:XXX): STEAM_0:0:526256772 Appeal Type (Apology or Dispute): apology Which staff member banned you?: hound How long is your ban for?: perma Why were you banned?: clapped whoreson on chiv Why do you deserve to be unbanned?: uhh my fault pimp can i be unbanned please i retired from chiv 2 Additional Information:

in certain situations last resorts aren't always necessary the guidelines are not absolute you were a primary suspect in a coup and so you were shot like a dog not given a fair chance to defend yourself because again a member of my command staff went missing as a direct result of this attempt. you committed a grave offense against the entire faction and that is why you were killed

you were pointed out as one of the key members during this situation in which one of my command members went missing as a direct result multiple peoeple stepped forward and identiefied you, jim gordon, and rudolph, rudolph was killed by the nsb for breaking fear rp so he did infact die aswell just not in the same way you did

+1

Hi I was there when you died. you did not break fear rp on one occassion but twice if you valued your character you shouldnt have broke fear rp when 15+ people pointed guns at you and told you to stop https://medal.tv/?contentId=iroh46wv4vZHrqDVE&invite=cr-MSxSbEksMjQ4NTAzMjQs&spok=d1337N0Jw7PP

+1

first of all I was not prosecuted there was no court trial you sound very misleading. You are also interpreting another's reasoning behind detaining you as an excuse, claiming that you did nothing wrong when in fact you did is also misleading, you have no idea his intentions you are not a mind reader and neither am I which is why I helped him. You have continued to say that these trustworthy individuals identified me at times when I wasn't online so that must mean they are not all that trustworthy. As for the innenminister shooting me well that has nothing to do with anything involving the situation with you, I was explaining how its impossible at any time that I was there for the situation with the Admiral and you in character had no idea about that so no reason for you to bring it up. You can't seem to get it straight whether I had more than one opportunity as in your reply before this one you said I had multiple now you are saying you gave me one. There was no effective way to roleplay up to your standard because you are pinning roleplay onto me that I wasn't there for and when Told to give up my accomplices I responded with confusion and you said well that's that then never said a word to me again. John Marlow is not the only officer in the infantry and he certainly isn't my direct superior. If memory serves me correctly The deputy of the 5th brigade along with the chief were on and if the infantry chief was on that would have been the person to go to if not the deputy or the general. My own department outing me as a deserter is pretty damming evidence not the people who you think are trustworthy and just because you think they are doesn't mean they actually are. And again it was not an arrest you were at no point in anyone's custody or in a cell you were momentarily detained for violating the law and you were given clemency by the feldmarschal I'm gonna have to agree that replies are getting repetitive so Until any evidence or something new is brought to light I will not be responding

So being put in cuffs for 2 minutes is not being taken into custody that is what being detained is. The detainment which you claim is an arrest was not infact illegal because you were out of uniform which in some cases charges could be brought up however the feldmarschal showed leniency and allowed you with the help of myself and an army officer to assist you in correct it. I was not taunting you It may have came off to you that way since you were mad you got thrown in cuffs over it but that's just your opinion. Obviously there wasn't much haste to rectify much because I was told directly by the feldmarschall to get in position for the wargame. And again I wasn't on this character throughout the day so how could I be apart of his gang? The gunfight that was started while the dupe was being set up was because a member of the heer had smacked one of the innenministers guards with his weapon and the guard started opening fire on him and the rest goes down as every gunfight between opposing factions goes down. After I died I ran back to the hangar where the innenminister and kaiser garde were all leaving where I made sure they were escorted out until the innenminister shot me. After this I respawned joined the line and waited for a bit when I started a conversation with some members of the luftwaffe until the feldmarschall yelled at me to go get set up for the wargame. There was never a moment at all in the hangars where I interacted with the Admiral. I can assume when he was leaded away is when all of his men withdrawled from the wargame and it only was with infantry and luftwaffe at this point in which I was participating in so I definetly was at no time trying to lure him away from everyone I was participating in the wargame every round. John Marlow as Thone mentioned above in his reply and his group committed crimes that would absolutely get him and the people that he did them with killed. The problem is that I did not commit those crimes. You keep saying that I was identified as a member of their group well there is no hardcore evidence that I am with them other than the word of mouth from high ranks all in cahoots with each other. You essentially had me killed because I was guilty by association When I infact barely associated with them and killing someone off of assosciation and assumptions is just simply lazy and does not abide by the pk guidelines due you not even 5 minutes into arresting me you had me against a pole calling staff already. My execution was not the last resort it was the first, When I said there was no way for me to get off that pole I meant to say there was nothing I could say to get off that pole. You wanted me to tell you about all of the events and the people when I didn't even know them. I couldn't have even told you their names let alone what They did. You are lying about giving me opportunities and you never even told me what I was arrested for. Again you are claiming I'm lying but haven't show any proof. Someone being trustworthy isn't grounds for a pk, to my knowledge you need damning evidence and testimony from people closely assosciated with that person none of that was given. In your replies you haven't referenced any eyewitness accounts from my own leadership just other departments that have the same aligned belief that I was apart of that group. Why did you not seek out my commanding officers or since you are so bold to mention the generals why did you not have my general identify me among these men. He was in the hangar when everything was going on and I was quite literally fighting right next to him during the wargame. You should have sought my leadership out instead of instantly taking me out back to get shot to actually get real testimonies and witness statements instead of getting a yeah he was there from everyone in the room behind barricades with mp40s and machine guns pointed at the door.

You were not taken into nobodies custody you were caught with a infantry uniform on put in cuffs for maybe 30 seconds then untied to fix it. I was there helping you with it ensuring you being the feldjaeger I talked about was as squared away as possible even. I find it odd how when you tried to arrest John Marlow you were stopped in your tracks by the Feldmarschall but when you got throwin in cuffs for actually doing something wrong nothing was said which clearly means we were simply doing our duty as a fellow soldier. God forbid one of your superiors caught you posing as a member of the infantry. And then you go on to say that others were trying to lure the Admiral and you claim thats the commotion I heard. After I got finished with you I stood in line for a bit and shortly after we had commenced the set up for the wargame. You also are still attempting to lump me in this group of people who committed all these crimes way before I got on my character. I would like you to specify what earlier events because again I wasn't here for the events the Admiral was talking about. If you are going for a grenadier who assisted his superiors with a uniform mandate breaking feldjaeger then I would need to call into question your thought process on executing me for that. You were in the front and loudest and usually people will just simply agree to whoever is being the loudest. I mean if I was hiding away in a room with a bunch of other people I would assume those people hiding with me are gonna back up what I say and that is exactly what happened. During my arrest I was asked only 1 question from the feldmarschall, and it was at the very moment I was arrested and he asked me did I really do this? And obviously I swore up and down that It wasn't me. But again it was a room full of the same people with the same intentions who will all agree to the exact same thing regardless. I was then rushed to a pole outside to be shot where I was told to give up my partners in crime. My response to that was what are you talking about because I in fact was clueless. How could I tell you stuff about people or the nature of their crimes if I was never there for it. I was actually speaking out a lot, pleading for you to explain yourselves, show me evidence, what is going on? None of you responded to me and all someone said to me was shut up. It was already made up in your minds that you were just gonna shoot me because within 5 minutes of me being arrested i was leaning against a pole. there is not much a dying man has to say about a situation he knows nothing about. I cannot convey my innocence to people failing to safety there weapons before the command is even given to take them off safety. I was actually in fact not a stones throw away from the kaiser Garde base sure I ran past it but I was actually apprehended the second time by the fishing pond and I continued to demand the things I stated above and was either ignored or told to shut up. I feel as if you are making up the fact I was roleplaying a below standard quality when you yourself said one thing then never again said anything. Nobody talked to me at all other than maybe saying shut up or insulting me. Well you said it yourself "I may not have been involved" which logs will back this up. I would like to know exactly where I lied under this appeal, I want proof of the stonewalling and low quality roleplay not you just making shit up. And I want to know how I was supposed to get off a pole where people were already taking aim to fire and the admiral reminding them of the commands to go by. It was impossible to get taken off of that pole because you the ring leader said one thing to me you failed to roleplay this out and instead you were just hell bent on killing me and moving on to the next unfortunate soul that did you wrong. There was absolutely no opportunities given and when I asked about the situation you said well that was your final chance as if I was given any others in which I was not.

well do I have news for you in this screenshot here it shows when I was told to get on for a wargame for reference I run on CST 1 hour behind EST. you stated that at 5:30 EST all of these events happened and I am stating that I was not there for any of that. The logs will back up me getting on around the time of my Friend messaging me to get on for a wargame and all of these events you describe above happened an entire hour before I got on the server. Logs Will also show that the only people I killed were. Marines, Luftwaffe, MOI, all of these kills are from the wargame I participated in. It is no surprise that I would leave out everything you stated above because I was not there for it and have had no knowledge of it until reading your reply. I infact was singled out because when dog heard my voice he started screaming thats him thats him when I simply did not take part in any killing of any feldjaegers nor MGD nor marines at the time of what you said above.

Character's name & rank: Grenadier Thorfinn Snoresson SteamID32: STEAM_0:0:526256772 Staff member who issued the PK (if you know): hound Explain why you were PK'd: I first got on my character when I heard there was a wargame going on with the MOI and I got in to participate in that wargame. When I got in I lined up and waited until I noticed a Feldjaeger with a fucked up uniform and helped him. Everyone was being chaotic and yelling and while I was over by the wardrobe helping a Feldjaeger with his uniform, the admiral starts screaming about something that I can barely here and I shrug it off and keep going about my day. I then fight in the wargame after that I patrol around the city for a bit then I come back to the bendlerblock with the Feldmarschall who said he needed everyone and I come into a room with marines and one feldjaeger who starts yelling "its him its him" then all the marines and him surround me and tie me up and say this guy threatened my life to the feldmarschall. They didn't give proof they didn't say anything the Feldmarschall just says ok and says take him out back. and then I get ran over and die then I get tooken back and then I get shot. Why should you be un-PK'd?: While others who were actually making threats against the admiral were making them in the advertisements I hadn't interacted with him the entire day. all the Admiral had to do was point a finger and all of his yes men agreed to it. They had no Idea what my name was They didn't fill out a single witness statement or anything, they simply said it was me because they know who I am out of character and they thought it was good enough and just went on with it. Additional Information:

the warrant has been served before, numerous advertisements in game were sent out telling you to turn yourselves in I myself specifically remember a scenario of saving you from the men trying to execute the warrant. the entire command of the NSB is not just 3 generals its all the COs below him. This was stated my the Justice minister and you yourself confirmed that the warrant was served previously just because some of the nsb command staff couldnt pull their heads out from their asses does dismiss the warrant. What dismisses the warrant is the justice minister and nobody else seeing how we reached a resolution and you were no longer in trouble

So yes I did not say a word when you were getting grilled by the minister. As you know its hard to get a word its a two man back and forth between you being defensive and him showing aggravation. After he left I did mention to you multiple times that I did not know of his intentions. As for me handing him the warrant it was the subject we were attempting to clear. Had nobody have found the warrant there was no guarantee to it being dismissed because while it could not be found it was still a known active warrant by a handful of the NSB and LAPO by giving him the warrant advocating for it to be dismissed I ensured that there would be no future problems I fail to see where you were so backed into a corner that you had to kill me