PK appeal Hans Braun Oberstleutnant

[Butter_Toast]

 

Character's name & rank: Hans Braun Oberstleutnant

SteamID (STEAM_0:X:XXX): STEAM_0:0:559464857

Staff member who issued the PK (if you know): Prime 

Explain why you were PK'd: I was in the Reichstag, federal council room with the Feldmarshall, members of the MOI, Ministers and more. They were talking about a situation that had to do with the Generalmajor Valentin they kept talking and while this was happening the MOI wanted me and others to leave the PM allowed me to stay so I stayed with the FM. Later during talks the FM decided he did not want to be there and just started walking away so I walked with him when we got to the main doors of the Reichstag and opened them 2 guards were outside 1 lapo and 1 kg they were blocking us saying that they Federal council session has not stopped and that they were not allowing us to go outside. While me and the FM tried getting out I radioed letting the military know something is happening at Reichstag. Me and the FM kept trying to get out and the MOI tried to reach the FM telling me to move the thing is it was impossible for me to move since there were people blocking the door, and behind me the MOI trying to get to the FM it was a total disaster. They kept telling me to move but I kept explaining that it was impossible to do so and I told them if they wanted me to move they needed to move back which they did not do. The MOI then started to try and tie me up I tried explaining to them to move and not to tie me they did not listen and tied me up by this point members of the military were already at the front of Reichstag seeing everything happen hostility's rose and shots were fired. Most people got shot and sent to the hospital but I was still alive in cuffs, I was getting dragged away in cuffs and I kept asking why was I put in cuffs the person dragging me said" "I was not compliant and I told you to move 3 times", I said " I couldn't move if there is people around me do you not understand that, if there is people around me how can I move, its very simple, if you guys moved back I would have moved". After saying that I was gagged  Here is the clip showing that happen: https://medal.tv/games/garrys-mod/clips/lqHt5PO5KiGmNiM5Y?invite=cr-MSx1SVosMTkyNTg2MDU0&v=30. So after being blindfolded, tied, and gagged for like 5 minutes I had no idea where I was. I literally had to ask the new person that was with me watching me to unblindfold me, I know I was gagged but I didn't want to bother staff as much about that so I literally said real quick unblindfold me pls. Which they did and I found out it was Hans Spiegel Infront of me I recognized him since he used to be in the Feld. I was still confused as to why he was here now and what is going to happen to me. After waiting for a bit I saw that he took his gun out and said "Hey man god bless" and shot me I was very confused and literally said "what" here is the clip: https://medal.tv/games/garrys-mod/clips/lqHx35eimwLQm1H55?invite=cr-MSwxYzIsMTkyNTg2MDU0&v=11. I later Dm Prime asking why I was even Pk he told me that many things, Case Files, and me escaping their custody. I can see why a pk was approved for me but the way they did it was horrible.

Why should you be un-PK'd?: I had no chance of not getting tied because if they tied me in the first place for "not moving" when I could not at all so I could not avoid that situation. Also where was the roleplay at all how I can know the situation or even explain if they are just going to blindfold me and gag me. I get there was a pk set for me but this PK was executed horribly.

Additional Information: this clip shows a staff named Donzoko letting me know that Prime was the one who approved it https://medal.tv/games/garrys-mod/clips/lqHy6WaLM_J-CkIit?invite=cr-MSxMdnosMTkyNTg2MDU0&v=30

Also I had an old clip of someone saying in looc that they had things against me that can get me PKed if I didn't "cooperate": https://medal.tv/games/garrys-mod/clips/loDZ4IXFKhuD6of50?invite=cr-MSwyV3gsMTkyNTg2MDU0&v=30 this happened October 28th 

[VapingSquirrel]

+1 

I mean this could've been done with a better roleplay.

[Andrew]

Just to be clear, your only two arguments are:

1. PK is invalid because you had no chance of not getting restrained, and

2. Lack of roleplay

 

I'll address both, but would like to make this clear before I do so. Thank you

[Butter_Toast]

Yeah I had no chance of not getting tied I had people all around me and I could not move even when I tried too, and there was lack of roleplay. 

[Andrew]

Denied.

17 minutes ago, Andrew said:

1. PK is invalid because you had no chance of not getting restrained

Lacking the chance to not get restrained isn't a factor in PK appeals, unless the inability to avoid detainment was a result of prop blocking or some other rule violation. Here, no rule was violated in regards to your limitation in movement.

 

18 minutes ago, Andrew said:

2. Lack of roleplay

This is a valid concern with PK appeals. In this situation in particular, there seems to be sufficient RP for a PK to be conducted. The roleplay may have not been the best, though not every seen is perfect, including back-and-forth dialogue for a specific amount of time, a viable chance for escape, etc., but is, nonetheless, sufficient for a PK to occur. An example of a PK scene lacking RP would be one with little-to-no interaction, such as sniping (which require UA approval and only occur under extraordinary circumstances).