Leaderboard

Your Name: Dartin Todger SteamID (STEAM_0:X:XXX): STEAM_0:0:597846008 Appeal Type (Apology or Dispute): dispute Which staff member banned you?: Major Whoreson How long is your ban for?: 1 year Why were you banned?: "Game is lagging sorry" Why do you deserve to be unbanned?: I killed the girl that said she would put a bullet in my head and catch a year ban ? i honestly do not understand this whatsoever only my second offense also

Character's name & rank: Oberfeldwebel Wolfgang Mayer SteamID: STEAM_0:0:922662423 Staff member who issued the PK (if you know): Prime Explain why you were PK'd: MRDM Why should you be un-PK'd?: Look, I'm not very sure whether, by the book, this was a fair PK, but I do know that an admin in a very similar situation told me I was fine. In both situations the same guy had told me to open fire, I did the same thing in each one, I was only punished in the second one. I feel like this was a lose lose for me no matter what, but that's not why I'm making a PK appeal, I feel this is a precarious situation. If I don't follow orders I get fired, or worse. I just want to keep playing. I genuinely enjoy the server. But by the logic of you not being supposed to fire when a higher ranking official orders it, doesn't that mean that every time someone like NCOs and enlisted who haven't deep dived the rules, are ordered to fire, they're gonna get PK'ed because they just didn't know better? Getting a direct orders from the highest rank of CO, and not fulfilling it is pretty serious stuff. So that also mean that CO's or other high ranks shouldn't even have the ability to give an order to open fire(or at least be warned by them that if lower ranks open fire AND DIE, they get PKed), and also, how am I not supposed to die here? Survival in a firefight against a crowd isn't something a person can just control, and if I die I get PKed. According to the server's own Government PK guidelines, initiating a shootout is what triggers a PK, but I didn't initiate anything, I defended a position under a direct order from a CO. If the rule is strictly "if you die, you get PKed," then any division combat where a soldier dies becomes an automatic character deletion, which ruins military roleplay entirely. I did not know the risk. Because the first time, it made sense that I didn't get PKed. To summarize, I didn't initiate a gunfight. I was given orders, I followed them to avoid punishment, and protect the Bendlerblock from a breach, and protect my superiors. I just want my character back, I feel like I deserve it, also Wolfgang Mayer is a cool name you have to agree. Additional Information: I have clips of both situations, in both I was told to open fire. The clips both show a very similar situation, it might be by the books, but I feel I shouldn't be PK'ed for it. Here are the clips: https://streamable.com/0vsi8e I would also like to state that I wasn't given a proper chance to be heard out before the PK was issued, if I was pulled into a sit I could've explained all of this. In the PK guidelines, it says that PKs absolutely HAVE to be a last resort(for important persons, which I believe I am as the role of Oberfeldwebel is pretty important, leading men, making sure they're properly trained, recruitment and more.), this didn't really look like a last resort. I do not believe that as an Oberfeldwebel(with a 2nd class Iron Cross that I earned as a Stabsgefreiter) , I am not subject to rule 4 of the PK guidelines. Under rule 10 of the PK guidelines; "You cannot order the death of more than five people for a specific situation." If you were to review the clips that I posted, in neither situations did I kill more that 5 people or even exactly 5 people. Furthermore, you can ask copernicus124, c8jet as well as Generalleutnant Gator(Lukas Falkner IC who was an Oberst at the time and gave the direct order) on discord, who even stated he can give full details to Upper Administration regarding the situation and the orders given. Copernicus's and C8jet's replies to my post have been strangely deleted, so I am putting their names here so they can still vouch for me. Just to be completely clear, I WASN'T WARNED THIS COULD RESULT IN A PK

+1 after multiple kidnappings and shootings the military was on lockdown. Forces then thought it was appropriate to march into the Bendler block to enforce their will. An order was given to open fire, he was just the first one to act upon that order. I don’t know why he died as this was a multiple skirmish situation where he and others were ordered to fire. He in fact did not MASS RDM or anything. Forces bypassed our general and were attempting to acquire our command members. We/he acted in response. i can give full details to UA

In such a rush, but you had time to keep trying to connect to the server for the next 10 mins after your initial disconnect?